|
Post by macSlainge on Jul 26, 2020 21:06:12 GMT
I am having trouble reconciling the "provinces available to claim" vs. the 2 maps and the P&H 0.1, as the desciptions/names vary in some cases. One thing that will help is clarifying which map to reference. The first map posted on July 6th appears to fit better than the second map published on July 11th, so I am going with the older version as the source of truth (please correct me if I'm mistaken).
Below is my best guess at how the P&H Tabs with Provinces, "Maps" (v1/v2) and "Provinces available to claim" align. First, the two easiest ones:
P&H "Bayard" is comprised of "Gododdin" (Breton/Saxon). P&H "Umbria" is comprised of "Bernicia" (Sidhe).
P&H Dal Riada lists "Circund/Aclud", which seems to correlate with "Aberdeen" (Sidhe) on the map (v1 only is Bernicia split in two?) P&H Dal Riada lists "Dal Riada/Lothian", which seems to correlate with Argyll (Dal Riatian, NOT Lothians) on the maps.
P&H North Holds lists:"Alba", which correlates with "Caithness" (Lothians) on the maps. P&H North Holds lists:"Oalriada", which correlates with Ross (Dal Riatian) on the maps. P&H North Holds lists:"Orkney & Shetland" (Dwarf) correlates on the maps, but is it currently one province or two? (only 1 in the P&H) P&H North Holds lists:"Herbridges" (sic) (Dwarf) correlates with Hebrides.
Is all of the above correct? Can we rename the P&H or maps so that they match, or will that mess up the excel formula references?
Thank you!
|
|
|
Post by Muirchertach Somhairle on Jul 27, 2020 1:17:44 GMT
Ah, this was something on my mind as well. A reconciliation here would help immensely with my trying to envision it all.
|
|
|
Post by Lidhuin on Jul 27, 2020 1:35:11 GMT
The P&H V 0.1 is out of date, and I'm currently working on V 1. I realized the names weren't just wrong, but in some cases actually extraordinarily wrong (like Lothian being on the opposite side of where it's really at). So the maps are up to date and the "available provinces" thread has the correct provinces.
So to reconciliate (before P&H v 1 is posted):
1. Yes. Bernicia/Umbria the Sidhe kingdom that would be if there were elves covers Bernicia & Aberdeen (the provinces) 2. Yes, Argyll replaced Dal Riata/Lothian 3. Yes, Caithness replaced Alba 4. Yes, Ross replaced Oalriada 5. It's currently one province 6. Yes, and will be correctly named Hebrides.
Also, while an excel will be available, it's largely unnecessary, and all the information will be posted in text form on the board.
|
|